Democrats’ midterm choices: Liberals, moderates, both?
ATLANTA (AP) — Pennsylvania’s Conor Lamb and Alabama Sen. Doug Jones, the new miracle men of the Democratic Party, offer a clear model for how to run in Republican territory: Focus on economics, not guns, immigration or President Donald Trump.
But that won’t be easy when much of the party is whipped into a fervor over those topcs.
As the party barrels into primary season, its biggest success stories star Democratic moderates who’ve run strong in Trump country. But much of the energy in the party is on the left, where an active base is calling for everything from single-payer health care and a $15-an-hour minimum wage to bans on certain weapons and ammunition. Finding the balance between the base’s demands and winning general elections is Democrats’ new dilemma as they look to toward to the November midterms.
The challenge will greet Democratic candidates across 75 targeted GOP-held districts that Trump won in 2016, as well as the 10 Democratic senators facing re-election challenges in states Trump won.
To be sure, most of those districts are friendlier to Democrats than Jones’ Alabama, which Trump won by nearly 30 percentage points, and Lamb’s southwest Pennsylvania House district, where Trump won by nearly 20 percentage points and Lamb maintains a lead of fewer than 700 votes. That race has not been called.
The questions of tone, emphasis and policy nonetheless hang over Democrats’ mission to flip the 24 GOP-held seats they need for a House majority and their path to reverse Republicans’ 51-49 Senate advantage.
House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, who is in line for a second stint as speaker if her party is victorious in November, says the dangers of competing — and sometimes unhappy — factions are overblown. “It’s not a question of ideology. We all believe in working families, that’s what unifies us,” she told The Associated Press. She added, “In order to win, it has to be an economic message.”
Republicans acknowledged Lamb’s strong performance this week in Pennsylvania as a wakeup call. But they also insist Lamb and Jones, who won his Senate seat last year, were unusual candidates. They competed in special elections where turnout is unpredictable, ran against flawed Republican nominees and, importantly, emerged unscathed from primaries.
Some top Democratic recruits face serious primary battles.
In southern New Jersey’s 2nd District, where Republican Frank LoBiando is retiring, the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee touts state Sen. Jeff Van Drew as “a bipartisan consensus builder” who wins his majority Republican legislative district easily. Trump won the congressional district by almost 5 points in 2016; LoBiando got 59 percent of the vote.
Yet liberals hammer Van Drew for opposing abortion and voting with the National Rifle Association. They’re backing retired teacher Tanzie Youngblood, who supports gun restrictions and abortion rights.
“Progressive activists have to save the party from itself, otherwise we’ll be represented by Republicans masquerading as Democrats,” Youngblood said on her campaign Facebook account this week. Democratic leaders, she said, “are out of touch with the base of the party.”
Lamb could be headed for a similar squeeze. Because of a new, court-ordered congressional map in Pennsylvania, he will need to start campaigning in a newly drawn district that is less Republican than his current one. There are already two declared candidates in that race, including a prominent local attorney who is to Lamb’s left on guns and health care.
Alabama’s Jones downplays those kinds of fights, insisting at a recent national party fundraiser that “it’s time to find the common ground.” Jones didn’t hide his support for abortion rights, but emphasized “kitchen-table issues” at every opportunity and pledged to work with anyone, even Trump. Since joining the Senate, he’s voted with Republicans to end a government shutdown that liberal activists wanted, but stuck with his party in voting against GOP-backed abortion restrictions.
A less strident approach, he said, “will lead us to the kinds of victories that I believe we’re on the verge of having in November.”
Democrats stress that may not be true in every race, dismissing concerns that some policy positions may be too liberal to sell in November.
Tom Perriello, who ran for Virginia governor as a liberal in 2017, said, “People are coming to realize that we have misunderstood how mainstream progressive thinking is.” He lost a primary to Ralph Northam, but pulled Northam to the left on some issues, including minimum wage. Northam won the general election by 9 points anyway.
Perriello noted that “the Republican civil war” hasn’t exactly abated.
Recent GOP history shows Democrats the very double-edged sword at issue. Republicans were fueled by the tea party rise in 2009 and 2010, winning a wave election that gave them the House and many statehouses around the country. But tea party nominees also cost them winnable Senate seats during Barack Obama’s presidency — Christine O’Donnell in Delaware in 2010, Todd Akin in Missouri in 2012. And those tea party nominees who captured the House in 2010 have often upended the GOP’s ability to get major legislation through.
Those dynamics now leave House Speaker Paul Ryan the target of aggressive attacks from two Democrats who want to oust him in his southern Wisconsin district, where Trump won 53 percent of the vote.
“Paul Ryan has shown no leadership,” says Cathy Myers, a teacher and Ryan’s local school board representative who is in a Democratic primary fight with union worker Randy Bryce.
Of course, Myers and Bryce both embrace a litany of liberal positions that leave national party leaders only cautiously watching the race, despite having identified Ryan’s seat as a target.
“With all due respect to the national party, the first thing I have to do is look to my district and find out what they care about,” Myers said, insisting her approach can defeat the speaker. “People want authentic candidates, and they want leadership.”
Associated Press reporter Lisa Mascaro in Washington contributed to this report. Follow Barrow on Twitter at https://twitter.com/BillBarrowAP.